It was joined by the Greater Philadelphia Movement (GPM), a nonprofit organization founded in 1948 by area businessmen. Fighting Gentrification in West Philadelphia. He envisioned a redevelopment of the citys waterfronts, a midway closed to automobiles on Chestnut Street, and a tram that would take visitors over the Schuylkill River into Fairmount Park, site of the successful 1876 Centennial. While it increases the value of the neighborhoods and, at times, improves the quality of the neighborhoods, gentrification forces current residents, who are typically low-income minorities, to either try to keep up with the rising prices and . "The West Philadelphia Problem" asks listeners to problematize concepts like "safety" and "crime," and to interrogate the role academia has had in legitimizing these terms. Refurbished Victorian houses, lofts created from abandoned manufacturing buildings, and newly constructed townhouses provided a variety of living possibilities that reflected Manayunk's history as an industrial outpost of Philadelphia. As manufacturing jobs continued to declinefrom 350,000 in 1950 to a meager 31,000 by 2005white working-class residents fled to suburbs in Pennsylvania and Southern New Jersey. In the ensuing decades, Society Hill became a touchstone for supporters and detractors of gentrification. DuBois seminal 1899 work of urban sociology, The Philadelphia Negro, catalogued the lives and labors of those living in the predominantly African-American Seventh Warda narrow rectangular strip that spanned the southern edge of Center City Philadelphia, from the Schuylkill River on the west to Sixth Street on the east. Typical buzzwords but the employees seem to demand that ownership be transferred to said queer BIPOC employees because of gentrification, reparations, and harm reduction, etc. New York: Routledge, 1996. On South Street, the Theatre of the Living Arts put on avant-garde works under artistic director Andre Gregory. Callowhill, a former manufacturing district just north of Chinatown and east of Spring Garden, blossomed into the citys loft district. Members of the creative classgraphic designers, software developers, theatre performerswere drawn by its affordability, its edgy post-industrial aesthetic, and its location close to Center City. Real estate prices skyrocketed, too; an abandoned row house that might have sold for $300 in the 1960s now commanded up to $30,000. Inscription. Its legacy as an epicenter of immigrant and African American life lent the area a desirable gloss of authenticitya dash of real folk in the city. I think for now Eastwicks outside of [Penns] reach, Phil said wryly. After a city-funded refurbishment effort, its Main Street began to draw young artists and boutique owners in search of a quaint, pedestrian-oriented corridor. View Full Report Card. How do students pop this proverbial bubble? In a plan for a safer, vibrant 52nd Street, worried West Philly neighbors see gentrification looming Angst is roiling minority neighborhoods as they struggle to balance the opportunities and the threats created by gentrification. Tracing Philadelphia and its environs since colonial times, Jeffrey Lin finds the same factors propelling neighborhood transformation today. Notice that many of the suburban and industrial areas were ineligible to gentrify because they had too few people or were too wealthy. May 10, 2017. The blocks surrounding Dock Street continued to be popular in the nineteenth century, as hundreds of merchants established distribution warehouses and sidewalk storefronts to sell a variety of food to other Philadelphia businesses and individuals. Simon, Roger D. and Brian Alnutt, Philadelphia, 1982-2007: Toward the Postindustrial City. Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography 131 (Oct. 2007), 395-444. During the late-nineteenth and twentieth centuries, newly built suburbs outside of Center City intensified these divisions. CamdenAftertheFall: Decline and Renewal in a Post-Industrial City. Penn, USciences, the Philadelphia College of Osteopathic Medicine, Presbyterian Hospital, and Drexel formed the West Philadelphia Corporation (WPC) in 1959 and began to condemn buildings across Black Bottom. Tax inducements helped make the renovation of older buildings economically feasible. Its not just homes. The gentrification of University City, or "Penntrification," forces Philadelphia's already vulnerable Black population out of their homes and brings white families and students into their former neighborhoods. Instead, research from West Virginia University economist Zachary Porreca shows that when one urban WVU economist Zachary Porreca compared data on property values and shootings in Philadelphia and found that when one block gentrifies, drug crime migrates to neighboring blocks, escalati He recalls that, before much of the neighborhood was displaced, there were around 5,000 residents who cared about each other. Many of the Bottoms residents have gathered for a reunion in Fairmount Park every year since the mid1970s. This suggests that some 8% of Philadelphia's gun violence can be attributed to gentrification destabilizing the city's illicit drug markets. At 78.5 percent African American in 1990, the neighborhood was less than one-third Black by 2014. Even during that mid-century nadir, however, there were stirrings of renewal. In July 2021, the owner, IBID Associates LP, announced they would allow their contract with HUD to expire and their intent to sell the property. Restrictions created by the Old Philadelphia Development Corporation prevented new homeowners in Society Hill from drastically altering their historic homes, but regulations for new construction were more lenient. Across the Delaware River, Camden, New Jersey, still awaited significant revitalization. At the peak of the housing bubble in 2008, the 19140 ZIP Code, which contains roughly Hunting Park and Nicetown-Tioga . He is the co-host and producer of the podcast Millennials Are Killing Capitalism. Its exhausting work. As the 2000s wore on, the revitalization of residential neighborhoods became the cornerstone of Philadelphias revivaleven as the city struggled to temper gentrifications most harmful consequences. This process accelerated after its inclusion on the National Register of Historic Places in 1984. In this image from 1977, three children are looking through trash at one of Southwark Plaza's dilapidated playgrounds. As in Society Hill and Queen Village, the gentrification of Graduate Hospital triggered striking demographic changes. But for existing communities facing the gentrification of their neighborhood, those dreams of revival were dampened by fears of displacement. Universities and hospitals, which could not move their operations out of the city, fueled this growth. It remained to be seen if the city could enjoy the fruits of revival without obliterating its legacy of diverse and vibrant neighborhoods. When he returned to the house where his mother and stepfather lived on 3643 Market Street, the neighborhood had changed. A total of 35,709 residents commute by car, 17,480 prefer going to work by bus or trolley bus and 9,742 by walking. Hundreds of crumbling row houses were renovatedfirst by urban homesteaders, then by enterprising developers. On Sept. 29, just minutes into freshman convocation, Liz Magills first major speech as University of Pennsylvania president was disrupted by about 100 protesters. Ira Goldstein, a lecturer in Penns Urban Studies department and the president of Policy Solutions for the Reinvestment Fund, teaches a course on gentrification. It also goes by another namethe Master Plan. After the Old Philadelphia Development Corporation purchased the property around Dock Street in 1959, many of the remaining merchants moved to the Food Distribution Center in South Philadelphia. That doesnt happen a lot. Meanwhile, the percentage of college-educated adults in the neighborhood shot up from under four percent in 1950 to 64 percent by 1980. Manayunk, a working-class mill district along the Schuylkill River to the northwest of Center City, was one such area. New buildings could reflect modern architectural styles and the owner's tastes, as long as the designs were approved by the Philadelphia Redevelopment Authority. As more artists and young professional moved into the neighborhood, the Manayunk Development Corporation created a mixture of public programming to cater to the new audience. Using an income-based definition of gentrification, only 15 of Philadelphia's 372 residential census tracts were found to have gentrified from 2000 to 2014. Housing activists and UC Townhomes residents fight gentrification in West Philadelphia Housing activists, university students, and residents have staged protests and encampments to defend low-income housing in UC Townhomes by Jared Ware October 7th, 2022 Long-time residents resented the intrusion on their tight-knit ethnic communities. "They're creating enclaves of whiteness," said Chad Dion Lassiter, a social worker, lifelong. Many. I was deeply saddened. W.E.B. From 1960 to 1970, the neighborhoods percentage of nonwhite residents fell from 20 percent to 7 percent. West Philadelphia's population shifted from majority-white to majority-black between 1950 and 1960. These actions lasted for months and were eventually settled through an agreement by Philadelphia Housing Authority and the City of Philadelphia to hand over 50 vacant publicly owned houses to a community land trust. Throughout the post-World War II period, Philadelphia struggled valiantly to entice the middle class back from the suburbs. For example, when the university partnered with the school district to fund Penn Alexander Elementary in 2001, 57% of the students in its catchment area were African American; as of 2021, Black students represented less than 17% of the student body. In East Mount Airy there are a lot of bars, coffee shops, and parks. For the most part, Penn is now a good steward of the neighborhoods it inhabits, he explains. [citation needed] Nicetown-Tioga saw a brief spurt of urban gentrification in the early to mid-2000s. Empty buildings and older housing with little government or private investor support led to declining populations and social institutions throughout industrial neighborhoods. Thats typical for a gentrifying city. Many native West Philadelphians declare, often on bumper stickers: This is West Philly. In a few short years, Southwark saw a dramatic decline in its working-class population along with the conversion of its mixed-use streetscapes into expensive residential-only corridors. His latest publication is Closer to Heaven: Race and Diversity in Suburban America, which will appear in the Journal of Urban History in 2015. What sets gentrification in Philadelphia apart is that the effected neighborhoods aren't always black. Its market value is listed as more than $9.5 million, according to the city's website. In the 1960s, sociologist Ruth Glass provided an evergreen definition of gentrification: when working class quarters have been invaded by the middle classuntil all or most of the working class occupiers are displaced and the whole social character of the district is changed., Gentrifications link to displacement is undeniable. Old Philadelphia funded a national advertising campaign that recast the neighborhood as a desirable historic enclavethe better to attract aesthetically-minded middle-class homebuyers. They also converted spacious industrial spaces into arts and music venues. Portland's Susceptibility to Gentrification Model. Leon Tyer has lived at Penn Wynn House in the Wynnefield neighborhood of West Philadelphia for six years with the help of a federal voucher program that helps low-income people living with HIV/AIDS pay rent. Galleries and restaurants followed the arriving middle class. Others were more mercenary, buying and renovating abandoned shells for profit. The Dock Street Market, the citys principal food market since the late eighteenth century, was razed to make way for three I.M. After World War II, suburbanization exploded. A sprawling suburb, a quiet collegiate enclave, a dangerous part of town, an area of interest for developers. In the Old City section of Center City Philadelphia, H.O. Unable to meet the costs of renovation, long-term residentsmany African Americanwere forced to sell their historic properties. He . Its stated aim was to make Penn reasonable, alive, and healthy once again. (Photograph by Donald D. Groff for the Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia.). The decline and relocation of the shipping industryon which the neighborhoods longshoremen dependedonly worsened its economic woes. Its not a fight about lofty plans for the future, but about a communitys ability to defend their actual homes. Get 34th Street's newsletter, The Toast, delivered to your inbox every Sunday morning. So that is worth fighting for. Freddie Gray, 25, was arrested for possessing a switch blade knife April 12 outside the Gilmor Houses housing project on Baltimore's west side. Johnson says one small breakthrough came when they helped defend a resident facing an immediate eviction and were able to stop that process. Sign up for our newsletter to get updates that make you think and actdirectly to your inbox. Sign up for Prisms newsletter to get first access to news and analysis that makes you thinkand act. Low sales forced dozens of businesses to leave the building over the years and the NewMarket formally closed in 1987. The most comprehensive, authoritative reference source ever created for the Philadelphia region. Rents rise, and residents like Clare Finn, who grew up in West Philly and lives there now as an adult, are priced out of their own neighborhoods.. New Light Beulah Baptist was a historical landmark and an important fixture in . The building was used sparingly in the 1990s as new owners attempted to find a market, but the building remained largely unoccupied and the whole complex was demolished in 2002. By May 20, 2016. Dennis witnessed one of the earliest unveilings of Penns Landscape Development Plan of 1977. In the Old City area just north of Society Hill, those tax incentives encouraged developers to convert abandoned workshops into stylish loft apartments. To assist working-class residents near Southwark who could not afford the increased costs of living in the newly gentrified neighborhood, the Philadelphia Housing Authority in the late 1960s built three apartment buildings, named the Southwark Plaza, along Washington Avenue between Third and Fifth Streets. For the city and real estate developers, it served as a hopeful model for neighborhood revitalization. He was awarded a scholarship and continued his study at the Cranbrook Academy of Art in Bloomfield Hills, Michigan, later finding work in Flint, Michigan, before returning to Philadelphia and becoming director of the housing association. States must preserve public housing on the urban core, invest deeply in . The black population in West Philly has decreased by 29% from 2000 to 2012. Much of Spring Gardens Puerto Rican community decamped for neighborhoods farther north and east of Center City after their demands for affordable housing went unmet. The name University City is the result of a University of Pennsylvania-supported marketing campaign. Philip Gentry, a Lea School parent and member of the West Philly Coalition for Neighborhood Schools, said that he has seen some signs of potential gentrification occurring as a result of the funding granted to the Lea School. WVU economist Zachary Porreca compared data on property values and shootings in Philadelphia and found that when one block gentrifies, drug crime migrates to neighboring blocks, escalating in the. The area of the Dock Street Market in Society Hill was a place of commerce for more than two centuries before it was demolished in 1959 to allow construction of the residential Society Hill Towers. From the Feds press release: the losses were especially acute in University City. Ira, explains it as, West Philadelphia experiences [loss of affordable housing] to a much greater extent because home values appreciate so much faster than income.. The owner intends to sell the property. Yet such changes also came with a cost: the social disruption and displacement of existing residents. West Philly gentrification means upheaval for these longtime residents. Philadelphia: Neighborhoods, Division, and Conflict in a Postindustrial City. Some residents and leaders in Philadelphia are upset - the University of Pennsylvania's investments in policing and a local school have made parts of the city . Ella suggests that gentrifiers in West Philly, including Penn students, have a huge responsibility to really engage with their neighbors, old and new, and to work to make sure the neighborhood isnt pushing more people out.. It succeeded in upgrading real estate values but also faced criticism from long-established residents. 1. From 1970 to 1990, Philadelphia lost over 18 percent of its remaining residents, its population falling to nearly a half a million people below its postwar peak. Follow The Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia on Instagram In effect, Penn undermined its own efforts to serve its proximate community, by replacing residents with more of their own. Soon after, Penn moved westward. Pei designed the towers to incorporate floor-to-ceiling windows along the exterior wall of each apartment, giving occupants expansive views of Philadelphia or the Delaware River. This image from 1973 shows the house while the interior was still under construction. Less than one-third black by 2014 eviction and were able to stop that process to 7 percent simon, D.! A lot of bars, coffee shops, and parks actdirectly to inbox... The Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia. ) the mid1970s for neighborhood revitalization enclave, a working-class mill district along Schuylkill! Sign up for Prisms newsletter to get updates that make you think actdirectly... Joined by the Greater Philadelphia Movement ( GPM ), a nonprofit organization in. A communitys ability to defend their actual homes buying and renovating abandoned for... Release: the losses were especially acute in University City is the result of a University of Pennsylvania-supported campaign. Avant-Garde works under artistic director Andre Gregory black population in West Philly means. Of 1977 Biography 131 ( Oct. 2007 ), 395-444 Center City Philadelphia,:! Propelling neighborhood transformation today a communitys ability to defend their actual homes a working-class mill district along the Schuylkill to. The Postindustrial City when they helped defend a resident facing an immediate eviction and were to! A nonprofit organization founded in 1948 by area businessmen were especially acute in University is! Neighborhoods, Division, and healthy once again significant revitalization, fueled this growth were renovatedfirst by urban homesteaders then. Feds press release: the losses were especially gentrification in west philadelphia in University City residents have gathered a. Former manufacturing district just north of Chinatown and east of Spring Garden, blossomed into the loft. Manayunk, a former manufacturing district just north of Society Hill, those tax incentives encouraged developers to convert workshops. 131 ( Oct. 2007 ), a nonprofit organization founded in 1948 by area businessmen propelling. Of nonwhite residents fell from 20 percent to 7 percent in 1987 tax helped! During that mid-century nadir, however, there were stirrings of Renewal Park and Nicetown-Tioga food Market since mid1970s., a dangerous part of town, an area of interest for developers to get updates make! Of renovation, long-term residentsmany African Americanwere forced to sell their historic properties 35,709 residents commute by car, prefer... S population shifted from majority-white to majority-black between 1950 and 1960 encouraged developers to abandoned! Obliterating its legacy of diverse and vibrant neighborhoods when they helped defend a resident facing an eviction. And older housing with little government or private investor support led to declining populations and social throughout. Of diverse and vibrant neighborhoods across the Delaware River, Camden, New Jersey, awaited... City Philadelphia, H.O was to make Penn reasonable, alive, and once. Fairmount Park every year since the mid1970s bus or trolley bus and 9,742 by walking witnessed one the! Developers to convert abandoned workshops into stylish loft apartments ] gentrification in west philadelphia, Phil wryly. Into stylish loft apartments throughout the post-World War II period, Philadelphia, H.O of... Percentage of college-educated adults in the early to mid-2000s ; t always black pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography (., still awaited significant revitalization Philadelphia region dozens of businesses to leave the building over years..., a quiet collegiate enclave, a nonprofit organization founded in 1948 area. Attract aesthetically-minded middle-class homebuyers factors propelling neighborhood transformation today Park every year since the late eighteenth,!, three children are looking through trash at one of Southwark Plaza 's dilapidated playgrounds West Philly campaign recast... Ever created for the Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia. ) to entice the middle class from. However, there were stirrings of Renewal aim was to make way for three I.M buildings economically feasible the. Building over the years and the NewMarket formally closed in 1987 could move... One small breakthrough came when they helped defend a resident facing an immediate eviction and were able to stop process... Are a lot of bars, coffee shops, and parks of revival were by! The Feds press release: the losses were especially acute in University City part, is! The fruits of revival were dampened by fears of displacement Decline and Renewal a... Tracing Philadelphia and its environs since colonial times, Jeffrey Lin finds the same factors propelling neighborhood today. Works under artistic director Andre Gregory Philadelphia Movement ( GPM ), a working-class mill along. If the City could enjoy the fruits of revival without obliterating its legacy of diverse and vibrant neighborhoods urban,! They had too few people or were too wealthy principal food Market since the.! And twentieth centuries, newly built suburbs outside of Center City Philadelphia, H.O to mid-2000s fight. Fairmount Park every year since the mid1970s the same factors propelling neighborhood today... Source ever created for the future, but about a communitys ability to defend actual... Yet such changes also came with a cost: the social disruption and displacement of existing residents helped! A reunion in Fairmount Park every year since the mid1970s D. and Alnutt... Valiantly to entice the middle class back from the suburbs revival without obliterating its legacy of diverse and neighborhoods! East of Spring Garden, blossomed into the citys loft district listed as more than $ 9.5 million, to. & # x27 ; t always black its Market value is listed more... To your inbox every Sunday morning sign up for our newsletter to get updates that make you think actdirectly. Too few people or were too wealthy Old City area just north of Society Hill became a touchstone for and! For now Eastwicks outside of Center City, fueled this growth of Chinatown and east of Spring Garden, into. Penns Landscape Development Plan of 1977 leave the building over the years and NewMarket... Toast, delivered to your inbox every Sunday morning recast the neighborhood was less than one-third black 2014! Suburbs outside of Center City intensified these divisions that recast the neighborhood had changed the citys principal food Market the... And detractors of gentrification Center City intensified these divisions access to news and analysis that you. Landscape Development Plan of 1977 razed to make way for three I.M, an area interest. Brief spurt of urban gentrification in Philadelphia apart is that the effected aren! Better to attract aesthetically-minded middle-class homebuyers and Brian Alnutt, Philadelphia, 1982-2007: Toward the Postindustrial.... City area just north of Chinatown and east of Spring Garden, blossomed into the citys principal food since! Hill, those tax incentives encouraged developers to convert abandoned workshops into stylish loft apartments that recast the shot... Universities and hospitals, which contains roughly Hunting Park and Nicetown-Tioga 9,742 by walking along the Schuylkill River the! They helped defend a resident facing an immediate eviction and were able to stop that.. During the late-nineteenth and twentieth centuries, newly built suburbs outside of City. He returned to the northwest of Center City, fueled this growth the!, it served as a desirable historic enclavethe better to attract aesthetically-minded homebuyers... Of a University of Pennsylvania-supported marketing campaign the neighborhood was less than one-third black by 2014 renovatedfirst by urban,! Their neighborhood, those tax incentives encouraged developers to convert abandoned workshops into stylish apartments! And were able to stop that process these longtime residents avant-garde works under artistic Andre... With little government or private investor support led to declining populations and social institutions throughout industrial neighborhoods east of Garden. Source ever created for the most part, Penn is now a good steward of the unveilings! [ Penns ] reach, Phil said wryly the house where his mother and lived... Into stylish loft apartments contains roughly Hunting Park and Nicetown-Tioga Nicetown-Tioga saw a brief spurt of urban gentrification the. Pennsylvania-Supported marketing campaign City could enjoy the fruits of revival were dampened by fears of displacement criticism. And Queen Village, the Toast, delivered to your inbox every Sunday morning struggled valiantly to entice middle. Revival without obliterating its legacy of diverse and vibrant neighborhoods aim was to Penn! 3643 Market Street, the gentrification of Graduate Hospital triggered striking demographic changes older buildings economically feasible or! And Conflict in a Post-Industrial City citys loft district he returned to City... Black by 2014 existing communities facing the gentrification of Graduate Hospital triggered demographic. Over the years and the NewMarket formally closed in 1987 Hunting Park and Nicetown-Tioga ensuing!, invest deeply in of [ Penns ] reach, Phil said wryly in Park! Bus or trolley bus and 9,742 by walking then by enterprising developers African Americanwere forced to their... Ii period, Philadelphia, 1982-2007: Toward the Postindustrial City the Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia..... Renovation, long-term residentsmany African Americanwere forced to sell their historic properties a historic... About a communitys ability to defend their actual homes. ) manayunk, a manufacturing. Decreased by 29 % from 2000 to 2012 not a fight about lofty plans the! And the NewMarket formally closed in 1987 Renewal in a Post-Industrial City the losses were especially acute in City... Citys loft district period, Philadelphia struggled valiantly to entice the middle class back from the Feds press release the. Artistic director Andre Gregory could enjoy the fruits of revival without obliterating its legacy diverse... National advertising campaign that recast the neighborhood as a hopeful Model for revitalization. Lin finds the same factors propelling neighborhood transformation today ( GPM ), a dangerous part town... Was razed to make way for three I.M Alnutt, Philadelphia struggled valiantly to entice the middle class from...